A company I recently worked with has decided to replace all their consulting partners with internal employees. Interestingly, this isn’t the first time they’ve tried this approach. About five years ago, they pursued a similar strategy, but it led to disappointing results. The goal of this shift is to retain intellectual capital within the organization and prioritize employees as the primary resource over external consultants.
This initiative is being driven by a new leadership team, recently hired into the organization. These leaders successfully implemented a similar strategy at their previous firm, replacing consultants with internal employees. However, the company they now oversee is vastly different. It’s far more diverse, operating across multiple businesses and spanning a global footprint. Managing such a widely dispersed workforce presents its own challenges, particularly when onboarding new employees across various locations simultaneously. While leaders are confident the new hires will adapt over time, it’s worth considering the lessons from five years ago.
Lessons Learned from Replacing External Consultants
A prior attempt replacing consultants with internal employees revealed significant challenges that disrupted both customer service and project performance. While internal staff were skilled, they often lacked the same level of dedication to quality and accountability as their external counterparts. Projects were frequently assigned based on availability rather than expertise, which led to subpar outcomes. Additionally, project managers often failed to take full ownership, resulting in delays, inadequate deliverables, and overall inefficiencies. These setbacks ultimately forced the company to reintroduce external consultants.
The value of external consultants became unmistakable through their results-driven approach. Bound by contractual agreements, consulting firms provided highly skilled professionals specifically matched to project requirements. Their precision, efficiency, and “white glove” project management style ensured tasks were completed on time and within budget. Consistently high performance wasn’t just a goal for these firms—it was essential for securing future partnerships with the company.
While the leadership team’s ambition replacing consultants with an internal-only model is commendable, the complexities of managing a global, multifaceted organization demand careful reflection on past lessons. Whether this renewed strategy will succeed or repeat history remains uncertain.
Potential Challenges and Considerations
Large-scale transformations inevitably come with challenges that must be anticipated and addressed to ensure success. For the leadership team, staying vigilant and proactive will be critical. Some key obstacles to consider include:
- Resistance to change from employees accustomed to existing processes and systems.
- Operational disruptions as new systems and procedures are introduced.
- Misalignment between departments or regions within the organization.
- Limited resources or budget constraints that could hinder implementation efforts.
- Technical difficulties or compatibility issues when integrating new technologies.
To overcome these challenges, a robust change management strategy is essential. This strategy should include clear communication, consistent employee training and support, and a structured approach to implementing changes.
Effective communication is the cornerstone of any successful change management initiative. Leaders must clearly articulate the reasons for change and its potential benefits to employees, fostering understanding and buy-in. Regular updates and open dialogue will ensure alignment throughout the process and help address employee concerns as they arise.
The Value of External Consultants
External consultants provide organizations with undeniable advantages. With broad experience across various industries, they offer unique perspectives that internal teams may not possess. Their contractual nature also fosters a strong commitment to delivering high-quality results, as their performance directly impacts their reputation and future opportunities. This accountability often pushes consultants to achieve outcomes that surpass those of internal employees.
While internal teams are essential to an organization’s success, external consultants bring unmatched dedication, expertise, and a customer-centric approach. The key to long-term success lies in striking the right balance between leveraging the strengths of internal resources and the specialized capabilities of external consultants. In this section, we’ll explore how working with external consultants can drive better business outcomes.
The Advantages of Partnering with External Consultants
Working with external consultants unlocks a range of benefits that can drive innovation, efficiency, and growth for your organization. Here’s how their expertise can make a lasting impact:
1. Fresh Perspectives and Creative Problem-Solving
External consultants bring an unbiased, objective viewpoint to organizational challenges. Free from internal politics and entrenched assumptions, they can analyze issues with clarity and propose innovative solutions that may be overlooked internally. This fresh, outside-the-box thinking empowers organizations to overcome stagnation and seize new opportunities for growth and transformation.
2. Specialized Expertise and Industry Insights
Consultants often possess highly specialized knowledge and skills that go beyond the scope of internal teams. Their deep expertise equips them to tackle complex challenges with precision and efficiency, offering solutions to persistent issues that may have eluded in-house efforts.
Additionally, external consultants stay ahead of emerging industry trends and best practices, ensuring their recommendations are informed by the latest developments. This foresight helps your organization stay competitive in fast-evolving markets.
3. Cost-Effective Access to Top Talent
Hiring external consultants on a project-by-project basis can be more cost-efficient than maintaining a full-time team with comparable expertise. By engaging consultants only when needed, organizations can achieve high-impact results while optimizing resources, making this approach both effective and budget-friendly.
4. Knowledge Sharing and Team Development
One often-overlooked advantage of working with consultants is the transfer of knowledge to your internal teams. As consultants collaborate on projects, they share valuable skills, insights, and methodologies. This empowers your team to grow and apply these learnings long after the consulting engagement ends, fostering a culture of continuous improvement.
5. Flexibility and Scalability
External consultants offer unparalleled flexibility, allowing organizations to scale expertise up or down based on current needs. This adaptability is particularly valuable during periods of change, growth, or uncertainty, ensuring the right resources are available at the right time.
6. Proven Best Practices and Tailored Solutions
Thanks to their broad experience across industries, consultants bring a wealth of best practices that have been tested and refined in real-world scenarios. They deliver tailored, high-quality solutions designed to meet your unique challenges, providing a level of professionalism and care that leaves a lasting impact.
Conclusion
Replacing consultants on a wholesale basis has proven to be a difficult move over and over again. Partnering with external consultants gives organizations access to fresh perspectives, specialized knowledge, and cost-effective solutions. Their flexibility, commitment to excellence, and ability to share knowledge make them invaluable allies in driving innovation, solving complex problems, and achieving sustainable success. By leveraging their expertise, you can propel your organization forward with confidence.
Click here for a post on becoming a successful independent consultant.