Agile and outcome delivery are two highly regarded methodologies in project management. While both approaches aim to deliver high-quality products or services, they have distinct differences in their processes and focus. Recently, a debate has emerged about whether one method is better, with some leaders proposing a switch from agile delivery to an outcome-focused approach. Let’s examine the key differences between these methodologies and consider whether they can coexist or if one should be preferred.
Agile Delivery Approach
The agile delivery approach is a project management method focusing on continuous iteration and team collaboration with stakeholders to deliver high-quality products. Initially for software development, this approach has been adopted by many industries and adapted to various contexts.
Some key characteristics of the agile delivery approach include:
- Iterative process: The project is divided into smaller iterations or sprints instead of one large phase.
- Collaboration: Teams work closely together and with stakeholders to ensure everyone’s needs are met throughout the project.
- Adaptive planning: As requirements change or new information arises, teams can adapt their plans accordingly.
- Continuous improvement: Feedback from team members, stakeholders, and customers is used to continuously improve the product or service.
- Focus on individuals: The agile approach values individuals and their interactions over processes and tools.
Various methodologies fall under the agile delivery approach, like Scrum, Kanban, Extreme Programming (XP), and Lean. Each has its principles and practices but shares core values of collaboration, flexibility, and continuous improvement.
Outcome Delivery Approach
The outcome delivery approach is a project management method that focuses on delivering specific outcomes or results instead of just completing tasks. This approach prioritizes value creation for stakeholders by defining clear objectives and measuring success based on those objectives.
Some key characteristics of the outcome delivery approach include:
- Outcome-focused: The project is driven by specific outcomes or results that align with the organization’s overall goals.
- Value-driven: Activities and tasks are prioritized based on their potential value to stakeholders.
- Agile mindset: This approach embraces agile principles like collaboration and continuous improvement, focusing on delivering specific outcomes.
- Data-driven: Evaluating success is crucial in outcome delivery, using data to assess if the desired results are achieved.
The outcome delivery approach is often used in industries needing quick adaptation, such as marketing, product development, and organizational change. It can also be applied to traditional project management, like waterfall, by incorporating outcome-focused practices.
Choosing the Right Approach
Both the agile delivery and outcome delivery approaches have their strengths and can be effective in different situations. The key is to understand the needs of your organization and project before deciding on an approach. Some factors to consider include:
- Project complexity: If a project has many unknowns or needs frequent changes, the agile delivery approach may be more suitable.
- Stakeholder involvement: If stakeholders need to be involved throughout the project, the agile approach’s focus on collaboration can be beneficial.
- Clarity of outcomes: If specific outcomes are well-defined and measurable, the outcome delivery approach could be a good fit.
- Organizational culture: The agile delivery approach suits organizations valuing flexibility and continuous improvement, while the outcome delivery approach fits those with a data-driven mindset.
Can These Two Approaches Coexist?
The answer isn’t simply yes or no. Agile delivery and outcome delivery each have unique strengths. The choice depends on factors like project complexity, team dynamics, customer needs, and organizational culture.
It’s important to note that an agile delivery approach benefits complex projects with changing requirements, while outcome delivery suits projects with clear objectives and deliverables. However, it is possible for organizations to adopt a hybrid approach by combining elements from both these methodologies.
Ultimately, the question about agile delivery vs. outcome delivery is no one-size-fits-all approach to project management. It’s essential to evaluate your organization’s needs and goals to determine the best methodology for your project. These approaches aren’t mutually exclusive and can be combined to create a customized strategy for your team and stakeholders. So, it is crucial to have an open mind and continuously learn and adapt as needed throughout the project. By doing so, you can increase the chances of delivering successful outcomes and driving value for your organization.
Click here for a post on Agile delivery tools and techniques.